Should a Creativity Coach Give Advice? What to Do When a Client Asks “What Would You Do?”

By /

Should a Creativity Coach Give Advice? What to Do When a Client Asks “What Would You Do?”

A creativity coaching client spends twenty minutes considering two possible directions for a new project.

They understand the advantages of both.

They understand the risks.

Then they turn to the coach and ask:

“What would you do if you were me?”

This is an important moment.

The easiest response may be to answer.

The coach may already have a strong opinion.

Perhaps one option appears more realistic.

Perhaps the coach has professional experience that seems relevant.

Perhaps the client genuinely wants a recommendation.

But if the coach immediately says:

“I would choose option A.”

the nature of the conversation changes.

The client is no longer primarily examining their own thinking.

They are now evaluating the coach’s answer.

This does not mean a creativity coach can never share information, observations, experience or ideas.

It does mean coaches should understand what they are doing when they move from coaching into advising.

The central question is not:

“Is advice always forbidden?”

A more useful question is:

“What would best serve this client in this moment, and am I clear about the role I am taking?”

This guide explores why clients ask coaches for advice, when answering may reduce client ownership, how to respond without becoming evasive and how creativity coaches can distinguish coaching, feedback, information, mentoring and consulting more clearly.

Contents

Why Do Coaching Clients Ask for Advice?

Clients ask for advice for many reasons.

Sometimes they genuinely believe the coach has information they do not have.

Sometimes the decision feels difficult and they want relief from responsibility.

Sometimes they want reassurance that the decision they already prefer is acceptable.

Sometimes they assume coaching means receiving expert recommendations.

And sometimes they are simply tired of thinking.

A client may ask:

  • Which project should I choose?
  • Should I quit this creative job?
  • Do you think my idea is good enough?
  • Would you publish this?
  • How much should I charge?
  • Should I change careers?
  • Which direction would you take?
  • What would you do?

The wording may make it sound as though the client needs an answer.

But before providing one, explore what the client is actually asking for.

For example:

“What would knowing my opinion help you with?”

The answer may reveal the real need.

The client might say:

“I think I already know which project I want. I’m just worried I’m making a stupid decision.”

The coaching conversation has now changed.

The issue may be confidence in decision-making rather than lack of advice.

Is Giving Advice Part of Coaching?

Coaching, mentoring and consulting can overlap in everyday conversation, but they are not identical roles.

A coach generally works to help clients examine their own goals, thinking, choices and actions.

A mentor may draw more heavily on personal experience.

A consultant may be engaged specifically to provide specialist recommendations.

The detailed guide on the difference between a creativity coach, therapist, mentor and consultant explains these distinctions further.

That does not mean a coaching conversation must become artificially restrictive.

A coach may possess useful knowledge.

The important issues are:

  • What role has been agreed?
  • What does the client expect?
  • Does the coach actually have relevant expertise?
  • Would advice help or replace the client’s thinking?
  • Is the distinction clear to both people?

Professional coaching benefits from role clarity.

What Should a Creativity Coach Ask Before Giving Advice?

When a client asks for advice, the coach does not need to refuse automatically.

But it is useful to pause.

Ask yourself:

  • Why is the client asking me?
  • Do they genuinely need information?
  • Have they explored their own view first?
  • Am I qualified to advise on this?
  • Will my answer become disproportionately influential?
  • Is giving advice consistent with our agreement?
  • Would another question be more useful?

This pause prevents advice from becoming an automatic response to client uncertainty.

It also helps distinguish useful contribution from the coach’s desire to solve the problem.

How to Respond When a Client Asks “What Would You Do?”

You have several options.

Option 1: Explore why the client wants your answer

“I can share a perspective if it would genuinely help. Before I do, what would knowing what I would choose give you?”

The client may discover that they want permission, reassurance or certainty.

Option 2: Return to the client’s view first

“Before I answer that, what are you currently leaning toward?”

This prevents the coach’s opinion from immediately becoming the reference point.

Option 3: Clarify the decision criteria

“What matters most to you in making this choice?”

The client may already have enough information once the criteria become clear.

Option 4: Ask whether they want coaching or expertise

“Are you asking because you want help thinking this through, or are you looking for specialist advice from me?”

This simple question can clarify the role.

Option 5: Share a perspective transparently

If sharing is appropriate:

“I can tell you what I notice, but I don’t want my preference to replace yours. Would that be useful?”

The role shift becomes explicit.

Why Client Ownership Matters

Imagine a client has two creative opportunities.

The coach recommends the first.

The client accepts.

Three months later, the opportunity goes badly.

The client may think:

“I only chose this because my coach told me to.”

Now imagine the decision succeeds.

The client may think:

“I need my coach to help me make the next important decision too.”

In both cases, excessive advice can reduce the client’s sense of ownership.

A stronger coaching process helps the client develop decision-making capability.

They may ask themselves:

  • What matters?
  • What evidence do I have?
  • What is uncertain?
  • What trade-off am I willing to accept?
  • What can I test?

The long-term objective is not to make the client better at obtaining answers from the coach.

It is to help them become better at working through decisions themselves.

This kind of client-centered judgment is among the broader professional creativity coaching skills that developing coaches need to practise.

Advice vs Information: They Are Not Always the Same

Clients sometimes ask questions that have factual answers.

Suppose a client asks:

“Do you know where I can find the application requirements?”

If the coach knows, there may be little value in responding:

“Where do you think you could find them?”

That can make coaching feel unnecessarily artificial.

Information can be shared clearly as information.

Another example

A client asks:

“Do you know a tool that allows me to organize visual references?”

The coach may know several possibilities.

Sharing them does not necessarily mean deciding what the client should do.

The distinction

Information:

“Here are three tools that can do that.”

Advice:

“You should use this one.”

Decision:

“Choose this one.”

The further the coach moves toward choosing for the client, the more carefully the role should be considered.

Advice vs Feedback

Feedback is another area that can become confused with advice.

A client may show the coach a piece of work and ask:

“What do you think?”

The coach should clarify what kind of response the client actually wants.

Possible questions include:

  • What kind of feedback would be useful?
  • What are you trying to learn from my response?
  • Which part would you like me to respond to?
  • Are you looking for a reaction, an evaluation or suggestions?

This prevents the coach from offering a long critique when the client only wanted to explore their own reaction to the work.

The guide on how to give effective feedback to creative people examines this distinction in more detail.

Should a Creativity Coach Share Personal Experience?

A coach may have relevant personal or professional experience.

For example, the client says:

“I’m trying to decide whether to publish independently or approach traditional publishers.”

The coach may have publishing experience.

Sharing that experience could be useful.

But there is a difference between:

“When I faced this, I chose independent publishing and it worked for me, so you should do that.”

and:

“I have some experience in that area. If it would help, I can tell you what I encountered, but your circumstances and priorities may be different.”

The second version identifies the limits of personal experience.

A coach’s experience is one data point.

It is not automatically the client’s answer.

Offer Options Without Choosing for the Client

There may be situations where the client genuinely cannot see alternatives.

The coach may be able to contribute possibilities.

For example:

“Would it be useful if we brainstormed several possible ways you could test this?”

The coach and client might generate:

  • A small pilot.
  • A private prototype.
  • A conversation with potential users.
  • A limited public release.
  • More research.

The coach has contributed ideas.

But the client still decides:

  • Which options matter.
  • Which fit their values.
  • Which are realistic.
  • Which they want to pursue.

This is different from saying:

“Run the pilot. That’s obviously the best option.”

Ask Permission Before Switching Roles

One of the most useful habits for creativity coaches is making role changes explicit.

Suppose the coach has expertise that may genuinely help.

Instead of moving silently from coaching to consulting, say:

“I have some relevant experience here. Would you like me to step out of questioning for a moment and share what I know?”

The client can say yes or no.

After sharing, the coach can return ownership:

“What, if anything, from that feels useful to you?”

This approach protects clarity.

It also reinforces the importance of discussing roles and expectations at the start of the relationship. A good creativity coaching agreement can establish whether and how mentoring, advice or specialist input may be included.

What If the Creativity Coach Actually Is an Expert?

A creativity coach may also be:

  • An author.
  • An artist.
  • A creative director.
  • A business professional.
  • An educator.
  • A performer.
  • A marketing professional.

The coach may genuinely know more about a particular issue than the client.

Expertise is not the problem.

Unclear use of expertise is.

Consider three different responses.

Coaching response:

“What do you want the portfolio to communicate?”

Mentoring response:

“When I built portfolios in this field, I found that…”

Consulting response:

“Based on the market and audience, I recommend restructuring the portfolio this way.”

All three may have value.

But they are doing different things.

A professional should know which role they are occupying rather than treating every contribution as coaching simply because it happens during a coaching session.

What If the Coach Does Not Know the Answer?

Sometimes clients assume the coach should know.

For example:

“What is the best platform for selling this kind of artwork?”

If the coach does not have current expertise, the professional response may simply be:

“I don’t know enough about that market to give you a reliable recommendation.”

There is no need to improvise expertise.

The coaching can then explore:

  • What information the client needs.
  • Where reliable expertise may be found.
  • What decision criteria matter once the information is available.

If the issue moves beyond the coach’s role or competence, another professional may be more appropriate. The guide on when a creativity coach should refer a client examines how to recognize those boundaries.

How Too Much Advice Can Create Coach Dependency

A client initially asks:

“Which project would you choose?”

The coach answers.

Next session:

“Do you think I should contact this person?”

The coach answers.

Later:

“Do you think this idea is strong enough?”

Again, the coach answers.

Gradually the client may begin outsourcing judgment.

Instead of developing:

“How do I evaluate this?”

the client develops:

“What does my coach think?”

This is particularly risky with creative work because there is often no objective correct answer.

A coach’s aesthetic preference, business preference or personal risk tolerance may begin shaping the client’s creative choices.

A useful test for the coach is:

“Is my contribution helping this client think better, or teaching them to check decisions with me?”

What If the Client Insists on an Answer?

Some clients will say:

“I understand all of that, but I still want to know what you think.”

This does not automatically create a problem.

The coach can decide whether sharing a view is appropriate.

A transparent response might be:

“I’m happy to share an observation. I want to be clear that it is my perspective, not a decision I can make for you.”

Then share the perspective briefly.

Afterward ask:

“What is your reaction to that?”

Or:

“Does hearing my view clarify your own, or does it pull you away from it?”

Interestingly, a client may hear the coach’s recommendation and immediately realize:

“Actually, I don’t want that at all.”

That response also provides information.

A Practical GUIDE Framework Before Giving Advice

The following framework can help developing coaches decide what to do when a client asks for an answer.

G — Get clear on the request

Ask:

“What are you hoping my opinion will help you with?”

Identify whether the client wants:

  • Reassurance.
  • Information.
  • Expertise.
  • Feedback.
  • A decision.

U — Understand what the client thinks first

Ask:

“What is your own view at the moment?”

Do not make the coach’s opinion the starting point unnecessarily.

I — Identify your role and expertise

Are you speaking as:

  • Coach?
  • Mentor?
  • Consultant?
  • Subject expert?

Do you actually have relevant knowledge?

D — Decide whether sharing will help

Consider whether your input will increase clarity or reduce client ownership.

E — Explicitly return the decision

If you share something, finish with:

“What do you want to do with that?”

GUIDE is not an official coaching model.

It is a practical reminder to avoid sliding into advice without noticing the change in role.

Examples From Creativity Coaching Sessions

Example 1: “Which project should I choose?”

Client:

“You’ve heard me talk about all three projects. Which one do you think I should choose?”

Coach:

“I have impressions, but before I share them, what are you currently leaning toward?”

Client:

“The book.”

Coach:

“What makes the book stand out?”

Client:

“It’s the only one I would regret not doing.”

The client already had important decision information.

Advice was not necessary.

Example 2: The client genuinely needs specialist information

Client:

“You worked in publishing. Do publishers normally expect a complete manuscript for this kind of project?”

If the coach has current, relevant expertise, they can be transparent:

“That’s a publishing-information question rather than a coaching question. I can tell you what I know, while being clear about the limits of my knowledge.”

There is no need to pretend factual expertise is reflective coaching.

Example 3: The client wants reassurance

Client:

“Do you think leaving this project is a mistake?”

Coach:

“If I told you it was the right decision, what would that give you?”

Client:

“Permission, probably.”

Coach:

“What makes it difficult to give yourself that permission?”

The request for advice reveals a deeper coaching question.

Example 4: Feedback rather than advice

Client:

“Can you tell me if this concept makes sense?”

Coach:

“Yes. What kind of response would be most helpful? Whether I understand it, whether I find it interesting, or suggestions for changing it?”

The coach clarifies the feedback request before responding.

Example 5: The coach has an opinion but chooses not to lead

A client is choosing between two business ideas.

The coach strongly prefers the first.

Instead of recommending it, the coach asks:

“What criteria do you want the decision to satisfy?”

The client identifies:

  • Creative interest.
  • Available time.
  • Financial risk.
  • Long-term fit.

Using their own criteria, the client chooses the second idea.

The coach may personally disagree.

That does not make the client’s decision wrong.

25 Questions to Ask Before Giving a Client Advice

Understanding the request

  1. What would knowing my opinion help you with?
  2. What kind of input are you looking for?
  3. Are you asking for information, feedback or a recommendation?
  4. What would you do if I did not have an opinion?
  5. What feels difficult about making this decision yourself?

Exploring the client’s own view

  1. What are you currently leaning toward?
  2. What do you already know?
  3. What matters most in the decision?
  4. Which option fits those priorities best?
  5. What is making you hesitate?

Clarifying missing information

  1. What information would make the decision easier?
  2. Is that information available?
  3. Who might have the relevant expertise?
  4. What assumption are you currently making?
  5. What could you test before deciding?

Checking the role

  1. Would you like me to stay in a coaching role or share relevant experience?
  2. Would a specialist answer be more useful here?
  3. What kind of expertise does this question actually require?
  4. How much weight would you give my opinion?
  5. Would hearing my preference make it harder to hear your own?

Returning ownership

  1. What part of what I shared feels useful?
  2. What do you disagree with?
  3. How does this compare with your own view?
  4. What do you want to decide?
  5. What will you choose?

Advice Can Sometimes Be Useful Without Becoming the Centre of Coaching

There are moments where a piece of information or a brief suggestion may save time.

The danger is not one useful contribution.

The danger is allowing advice to become the default mechanism of the relationship.

If every problem ends with:

“Here’s what I think you should do…”

the coach may gradually become:

  • A decision-maker.
  • A creative director.
  • A consultant.
  • A source of permission.

Those may be legitimate professional roles.

But they should not be confused with coaching.

Common Mistakes Coaches Make When Giving Advice

1. Answering too quickly

The client asks for an opinion and the coach supplies it before understanding why the client wants it.

2. Believing experience automatically transfers

What worked for the coach may not fit the client’s circumstances.

3. Presenting preference as expertise

“I like option A” is not the same as evidence that option A is professionally better.

4. Giving advice outside competence

The coach feels pressure to have an answer and speaks beyond their expertise.

5. Hiding advice inside a question

“Don’t you think you should focus on the book?”

This is a recommendation wearing a question mark.

6. Failing to ask permission

The conversation moves suddenly from coaching into mentoring or consulting without acknowledging the change.

7. Giving too many ideas

The client becomes more overwhelmed than before.

8. Becoming attached to the client’s decision

The coach feels disappointed when the client chooses differently.

9. Using advice to avoid silence

The client does not immediately know the answer, so the coach fills the uncertainty.

10. Creating dependence

The client gradually loses confidence in decisions that have not been validated by the coach.

Many early coaching mistakes come from trying too hard to be useful. The article on 15 Common Mistakes New Creativity Coaches Make in Client Sessions explores other patterns that can unintentionally reduce client ownership.

What Trainee Creativity Coaches Should Practise

Trainee coaches often arrive with valuable knowledge.

The challenge is learning when to use it.

After a practice session, review every moment where you offered an idea, suggestion or recommendation.

Ask yourself:

  • Why did I share it?
  • Did the client ask for it?
  • Was I actually qualified to offer it?
  • Did I ask what the client thought first?
  • Did my suggestion narrow the conversation?
  • Did the client appear to treat my opinion as the correct answer?
  • Could I have asked a useful question instead?
  • Did I return ownership afterward?

Practice identifying the role

After each intervention, ask:

Was I coaching?

Was I informing?

Was I mentoring?

Was I consulting?

There is value in recognizing the difference.

Professional coach development begins partly with this kind of self-awareness.

Advice Should Never Replace a Client’s Right to Choose

Even when a coach shares a useful recommendation, the client remains responsible for their life, creative work and decisions.

The coach can say:

“Here is one perspective.”

But not:

“This is what you have to do.”

The coach can offer:

  • Information.
  • Experience.
  • Observations.
  • Questions.
  • Possibilities.

But the client’s ownership should remain visible.

A strong coaching relationship gradually helps the client need fewer external answers, not more.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should a coach give advice?

Coaching generally emphasizes helping clients develop their own thinking and decisions. There may be situations where information, experience or suggestions are useful, but coaches should remain clear about when they are moving into an advising, mentoring or consulting role.

What should a coach say when a client asks “What would you do?”

Explore why the client wants your opinion and ask what they currently think before answering. If sharing your perspective is useful, make clear that it is one perspective rather than the client’s decision.

Is giving information the same as giving advice?

Not necessarily. Providing factual information can be different from recommending what the client should choose or do.

Can a creativity coach share personal experience?

Yes, when it is relevant and appropriate, but personal experience should be identified as experience rather than universal evidence of what the client should do.

What is the difference between coaching and consulting?

Coaching generally emphasizes the client’s thinking, goals and decision-making, while consulting more commonly involves expert analysis and recommendations. The exact professional arrangement should be clarified with the client.

What if the client specifically wants advice?

Clarify what type of advice they want, whether you have the appropriate expertise and whether providing it fits the agreed professional relationship.

Should a coach ask permission before offering a suggestion?

Asking permission can make a role change more transparent and gives the client a choice about whether they want the input.

What if the coach does not know the answer?

Say so. Coaches do not need expertise in every area. The client can identify what information or specialist support they need.

Can too much advice make a client dependent on a coach?

Yes. If clients repeatedly rely on the coach to evaluate ideas and make decisions, their confidence in their own judgment may become weaker rather than stronger.

How can trainee coaches stop giving too much advice?

Notice the impulse to solve the problem, ask what the client already thinks, distinguish coaching from mentoring or consulting and reflect afterward on moments where advice entered the conversation.

Develop Professional Creativity Coaching Judgment

Knowing when to ask a question, when to listen, when to provide information and when to acknowledge another professional role requires judgment.

That judgment develops through structured learning, practice, reflection and experience with real coaching conversations.

People considering professional training can explore the Creativity Coach Certification Program.

You can also review the Online Creativity Coach Certification Course.

For UK-focused training information, visit the Creativity Coaching Certification Program in the United Kingdom.

Professionals researching training specifically in London can explore the Creativity Coaching Certification Course in London.

Scroll to Top